Here is the first installment of the overall rankings. There seem to be a few obvious drops. It’s a good year to have a pick in the top 6, or top 7 depending on how much you like Steve Nash. Those 7 players are sure things. After that there’s a drop at either 12 or 13, as the status of Dwyane Wade makes him a real wildcard at this point. For the rest of the top 25 it’s really whoever you like best. You could really make arguments for pretty much everyone on here, although there does seem to be a bit of a drop after 23, or 24 depending on if you would dare use a 2nd round pick on Marcus Camby.
(For the record, these rankings are assuming non-turnover, non-H2H roto leagues.)
1. Kobe Bryant: Really, who didn’t demand a trade this summer? Bryant isn’t going anywhere and he will spend another season carrying the load for the Lakers and putting up eye-popping numbers in the process. He was the #2 player per game last year and #1 overall. He was #2 both per game and overall in 05-06. He’s still in his prime, isn’t a substantial injury risk and will once again be the focal point of his team’s offense more than any other player in the league. He’s not a no-brainer choice at #1 like KG was for so many years, but he’s the top player on this board.
2. Kevin Garnett: How much will the change of scenery affect his numbers? That’s the big question with the Big Ticket. He’s put up roughly the same numbers for the past decade, although his assists have dropped off big time over the past two years. Still, his 7-category fantasy dominance is unquestioned. When you’ve got such a good thing going, a change usually isn’t for the best, but Garnett should be fine in his new home. At the end of the year expect another 21/13/5, 50/80, 1.5/1.5 season. And if something happens to Kendrick Perkins and Garnett gets some run at center? Well, then he becomes a fantasy god.
3. Shawn Marion: The Matrix isn’t going anywhere, OK? He’ll remain in Phoenix, the best possible fantasy situation for him. That said, cracks are starting to show in Marion’s facade. He only missed two games last year, but was frequently banged up, dropping from 40.3 mpg to 37.6 mpg. He averaged just 17.5 ppg, his lowest since 00-01 and didn’t average double-digit boards after topping 11 per game in the previous two seasons. All that said, he finished the season as the #2 ranked player (#5 per game). It seemed like this was the year people were finally looking at Marion as a legit #1 pick, but these questions have tempered that. He remains a no-brainer for the top 5.
4. LeBron James: Hit a free throw, LeBron, would ya? Shooting 70% from the line is truly unacceptable, and four straight seasons of declining percentage at the stripe makes you think it’s getting in his head and not that easily reversible. The rest of his numbers were down, too, as he seemed to coast through the season at times. Let’s not be too down on him for that, though. Here’s a guy who’s been playing 40 mpg every night since he was 18 years old, if he wants to save himself a bit, that’s fine. He’s still the only player in the league that has the potential to throw up a 32/8/8 season, and for the true believers, that’s enough to take him at #1. Going strictly by numbers he’s closer to #10, so split the difference and you’re where you should be.
5. Gilbert Arenas: The Takeover Season went as planned until Agent Zero went down with a knee injury late in the season. That should give owners slight pause, but early reports seem to indicate that the Black President will be just fine. Arenas is basically the new Allen Iverson, with a few less steals and loads more 3s. He’s a high volume, low percentage shooter who will drag down your FG%, but that’s the only negative to his fantasy game. He finished as a top 5 contributor in four categories last season, and was top 20 in assists. He has the potential to be the #1 fantasy player and when he’s hot, no player is more fun to own.
6. Dirk Nowitzki: Dirk has become a bit more boring the past couple years, but he remains one of the most reliable fantasy stars around, which is always a good thing to have in a first round pick. The days of 1.5 blocks and 3s per game seem to be in the past, but he’s become deadly accurate from everywhere on the court. He never misses more than a handful of games, always gets his shots and opportunities (except in the playoffs, of course) and is in the middle of his prime. He may be the least exciting of the top tier players, but he’s also the steadiest.
7. Steve Nash: Somehow, he keeps getting better. That’s not how it’s supposed to be with 33 year old point guards with chronic back problems. Nash shot a mind-blowing 53% from the field last year, as he and Tony Parker were miles better than any other guard in that category. He’s a guarantee to lead the league in assists, hit 2.1 3pg last year and was his usual sterling self from the line. And for all the talk about the back problems and getting old, he’s missed a total of 20 games in the past 6 seasons. He won’t play 40 mpg that most of the other first rounders will, but Nash knows what he needs to do to suit up every night. You can convince yourself that a drop-off is imminent, but the numbers don’t back that up.
8. Yao Ming: As Yao refines his game, he plays fewer games. His line of 25/9.4/2 with 2 blocks on 52/86 shooting is fantastic, but he only played in 48 games. That makes two consecutive seasons in which he’s missed a huge chunk of time. Both injuries have been more freak than chronic, but you have to remember that he’s a 7’6”, 300 pound dude – players like him have a tendency to break down. Getting a dominant center early is always a plus, but what happens if he gets hurt and you don’t have a third solid center? You not only lose a first round pick, but you replace him with someone from the waiver wire. Just something to think about before taking him in the first round, which someone will surely – and rightly – do.
9. Amare Stoudemire: In the season everyone got hurt, it was the guy coming off of microfracture surgery that appeared in 82 games. OK, his recent knee surgery is certainly a reason to be concerned, although he looks like he should be OK to start the season. On the plus side, he’s already proven he can come back from the most serious knee surgery possible. Stoudemire was almost as good as ever last year, he just didn’t play as much since the Suns wanted to take care of him. He’s a FG% machine and surprisingly accurate at the line. He doesn’t rack up huge rebound and block numbers, at least for a center, but that’s a minor complaint. Here’s why you wait as long as possible to hold your draft. He’s an obvious first rounder if he’s feeling OK, it’s just hard to know for sure at this point.
10. Jason Kidd: Forget the concerns about his knee surgery from a few seasons ago and his poor FG% — Kidd has proven himself to be one fantasy’s most valuable and underrated players. Kidd has remained incredibly consistent over the last three seasons, with his PER staying between 19.2 and 19.7, and his fantasy numbers have held strong as well. But what made him especially valuable last year was that when most of the league was getting hurt, he played in 80 games for the second straight season. Some may think the extra games during the summer would make Kidd more prone to injury this season, and with older players there’s always an excuse you can make that a decline is imminent. But the fact remains that you can basically use permanent marker to write him in for at least 13/8/8 with 1.5 3s and 1.5 steals, and that’s the low end on a bunch of those numbers. He’s as solid a late first round pick as you’ll find.
11. Chris Paul: Stardom on hold, if only briefly. A badly sprained ankle caused him to miss a month and then a foot injury gave him fits down the stretch, but Paul still flashed the skills that helped him run away with Rookie of the Year honors on 05-06. His saw a slight drop in boards and steals, but he was a better and more efficient scorer and also added a full assist, taking him to 8.9 per game. If Paul is truly healthy — still a slight question mark at this point — he could see a significant third-year leap, especially if he’s healthy and can handle a few extra minutes per game. The end of the first round is really a “who do you like best?” situation? There are plenty of reasons to like Paul best.
12. Pau Gasol: Gasol came back with a vengeance after missing the first 22 games of the year due to a broken foot. He was a risky pick on draft day but met his timetable, was eased back into action and was a dominant fantasy player over the rest of the season. He notched career highs in points, rebounds, blocks, FG% and FT% en route to finishing the season as the #16 player per game. He’s had only two injuries over his six years, but it is worrisome that both were foot injuries. Still, he’s not a significant injury risk, qualifies at center and is in his prime at 27 years old. The tail-end of the first round is so up in the air this year that a solid argument can be made for taking Gasol there.
13. Dwyane Wade: It doesn’t matter how great you are – and Wade is pretty much the greatest around right now – but you can’t accumulate numbers if you aren’t playing. And right now, we just don’t know how much Wade will play. He won’t even be able to practice for real until the middle of November, so early December seems to be a best-case scenario. Only 51 games of Wade was good enough to make him the 25th best player overall last year, so he’s still worthy of an early round pick. He’s the ultimate risk/reward, and spending a first round pick on the ultimate risk just isn’t something we can endorse, even if he is the best out there.
14. Andre Iguodala: Iguodala’s emergence as a fantasy superstar is complete, and it didn’t take too long. The departure of Allen Iverson was the key, of course, but Iguodala came through with flying colors once he became the franchise player. Despite missing games for the first time in his career (only 6, nothing to worry about) he finished the season as a top 15 player and there’s no reason to expect anything different this season. His FG% declined as his role increased, but when you put up 18.2/5.7/5.7 with 2 steals, you can deal with 45% shooting. There’s no reason to expect those numbers to go down, and if he shows even slight improvement and plays in 82 games – both reasonable expectations – he could end up a first round value.
15. Tim Duncan: Ho-hum. It was a banner season for Duncan, who turned in his second straight 80-game campaign, bounced back with big FG% and block numbers and, of course, led the Spurs to another championship. There’s no reason to expect much change in 07-08, although it wouldn’t be a surprise to see him miss more than just a couple of games. His poor free throw shooting remains a sizeable handicap in roto leagues and Duncan’s reputation as an unexciting player translates into fantasy. Because he’s unlikely to shoot 54.6% or stay quite as healthy again, he shouldn’t be a first rounder.
16. Josh Smith: I remain skeptical of Josh Smith, but fantasy is about numbers and Smith has a few that you can’t ignore. The first is obviously 2.9, which is how many blocks he averaged last year, a truly phenomenal number for a G/F. The next most significant number is 21, which is how old Smith will be on opening night, meaning that there’s a reason for his inconsistency and that there’s every reason to believe he has room for improvement. He was a top 25 player however you shake the numbers, and his trends in boards, assists, steals and points are all positive. He averaged 18.9 ppg after the break and if he can score like that night in and night out and keep up those inhuman block numbers, he’ll prove to be worth the second round pick it’ll cost you to get him.
17. Rashard Lewis: From perennially underrated to one of the most overpaid players in the league. Lewis had carved out a comfortable niche in Seattle as a little-bit-of-everything and experienced his best season statistically last year, despite missing 22 games. The Magic are paying him so much money that they will have no choice but to feature him on offense, which bodes well for his fantasy value. Hopefully he won’t lose his motivation now that he’s guaranteed $115 million, or whatever obscene amount it is, and he’ll continue to knock down 3s and pour in 20+ ppg. He makes a relatively safe second round pick.
18. Vince Carter: Carter’s been remarkably consistent during his time in New Jersey, putting up second round numbers, which last year translated into first round value thanks to his appearing in all 82 games. Yes, all 82 games. It’s time to remove the “injury prone” tag from Vinsanity, as he’s been nothing but a perfect picture of good health in the Garden State. He’s signed to a long-term contract now, so perhaps some of his motivation will be gone, but unless the Nets start to really falter there’s no reason to expect anything besides the 25/6/4.5 he’s averaged the last few years. After being overrated for so long, Carter may actually be an underrated fantasy property at this point in his career.
19. Chris Bosh: Bosh’s fourth season was almost identical to his third, save for a 1.5 jump per game in rebounds, taking him up to 10.7. Otherwise his points, FG%, assists, steals, blocks, minutes and games played were all near his 05-06 levels. So it’s quite possible that what you see right now is what you get with Bosh. And that’s very good, if not quite great. His center eligibility makes him more attractive, but his injury history is cause for at least a bit of concern. He’s yet to crack the Top 20 on per-game player raters but is being drafted higher than that. We’ll see if he has one more level to his game this season; if not, he looks like a mid-second round pick for at least the next five years.
20. Carmelo Anthony: I love ‘Melo this year. He proved that his third-year leap was no fluke, and if it wasn’t for his silly suspension brought on by some idiot cry babies on the Knicks, he would have finished the season as a top 20 player. You can call him “just points” if you want, but he’s now shot 48% from the field in consecutive seasons, and when you take 20 shots per game, that’s plenty valuable. He gets to the line, has upped his boards and rebounds, and you simply can’t scoff at 29 ppg. Say it’s “just points” if you will, but he was as valuable in points last season as Gilbert Arenas was in 3s. Him and Iverson should be on the same page and motivate each other. Anthony may not have the flashiest fantasy game, but you know he’ll be out there scoring every night.
21. Allen Iverson: He’s not the #1 option for the first time in his career and I think he might actually like it. There are still plenty of points to go around in Denver, and if he averages 25 instead of 30 but shoots 45% instead of 41% — which is what happened last year – it’s a fair tradeoff. Chucky Atkins should handle point guard duties, but he’s not really a true point, so it’s possible The Answer could top the 7.2 apg he averaged last year with Denver. One way AI could offset the slippage in his fantasy game is to hit more 3s, which is always a possibility in Denver’s fast-paced, high-scoring offense. You know he’ll see plenty of minutes but you also know he’ll be banged up a bit. Looking at his current numbers, 05-06 season is a clear outlier, so as long as you aren’t expecting a repeat of that, you shouldn’t be disappointed.
22. Ray Allen: There are plenty of warning signs with Allen, but most of them have to do with general history of players like Allen, not Allen’s own track record. He’s been remarkably consistent over his career and actually averaged a new high of 26.4 ppg last season. He didn’t match his 3s bonanza of 05-06, but his 3.0 per game were still huge. His double ankle surgery and age – 32 – are worrisome, especially given his position. The fact that he’s going from the #1 scoring option to one of three top scoring options also brings some uncertainty to the table. The good thing about Allen is that you know you’re getting dominant 3s and FT%. He was a top 10 player last year and Boston will need him to score plenty.
23. Paul Pierce: Even the top workhorses break down once in a while, and that’s what happened last year with Pierce. One of the most consistently durable players around missed nearly half the season and he saw significant enough drops in every category – except, notably, 3s – that he barely finished as a top 30 player on a per-game basis. It will be very interesting to see how Pierce adapts to having Allen and Garnett around. It’s easy to see him being more of a facilitator in order to make his new teammates comfortable, but that’s just speculation. It’s a better bet to count on him to continue his normal production, and if he can get back to playing 82 games that will make him a valuable second round pick.
24. Marcus Camby: He’s 33 years old and when he missed 12 games last year, that was shockingly good. He’s been a top 15 player on a per-game basis the past two years, is a rebounds/blocks machine and it’s always great to get a dominant big man early in the draft. If you’re a risk-taker, he’s right up your alley. But man, it’s just too dangerous for me. In his defense he’s played at least 66 games in three of the past four years, so his years of missing months at a time seem to be behind him. He’s the center version of Baron Davis, or maybe it’s vice versa at this point. He will certainly get drafted in the top 30, and if you think you can make up for his absence for at least 15 games, you could be greatly rewarded.
25. Chauncey Billups: Another fine year for Mr. Consistency, but he’s starting to show signs of a point guard that is wearing down. He missed the most games of his Detroit career, lost 1.4 assists and was off all season from long range. He was still a top 30 player, but a bounceback might not be as much of a given as you’d think. If he can just regain his stroke from long range that might be enough for fantasy purposes, though. After two years of 43% he dropped to 34.5%, and that meant 1.6 3pg instead of 2.3 3pg. He still holds the keys to the Detroit offense and is a force at the free throw line, but expecting another 05-06 might be a bit much.